Which Button?

[patrick6]

I was hoping some of you might take a look at these three buttons and tell me which you like best? (Or if you have a better idea I am all ears)

Thanks
Patrick

[yosik]

Patrick,
Definitely the third one. But you have a logical flaw there. If you have a drop shadow, when you click on the button, you shouldn't have a reversed (pressed) button, but more one that is pressed down and therefore has no shadow. Something more like the attached files. (just change extensions from zip to btn
Yossi

[patrick6]

closer

Here's the new try. It's closer but still doesn't quite look as realistic as the yellow one you did....

I'll keep working at it.

Patrick